2 in 1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set Water Proof Smudge Proof, Last for All Day Long, Work Great with Eyebrow, 2 Pieces Eye Makeup Brushes Included

This is the best eyeliner to have in your makeup collection. It goes on smooth and does not flake or wear off. I got the brown and black. I use the black on top with the slanted brush and I use the brown on the bottom with the tip brush, it helps give the smokie eye effect. I absolutely love this product and will buy more.

im a fan !!! it’s very smooth and can be easily applied on. I feel very fancy when I apply it , either on my brows or as eyelinernot as smudge resistant but does stay / seems pigmented after a while . it is waterproof though !!would recommend 😊

This stuff is the bomb as far as being easy to apply and the look of it. I use powder under my eyes to keep it from smearing, but I have to do this with all of my eyeliners (even those that claim to be waterproof). The only issue I had is that one of the brushes broke after the second use. I can probably fix it with super glue since the brush part separated from the handle. I have other eyeliner brushes that I can use also.

This product goes on smooth and effortless. It’s what I’ve been looking for.

I really liked this eyeliner at first, but then I didn’t. But first the good. It is highly pigmented, I love that it’s smudge proof and doesn’t transfer onto hooded eyelids or collects in the corners of my eyes. If you have never used an eyeliner brush, it may require some practice, but it glides on nice, and smooth.Now the not so good. On June 21, we lost my little brother (42 YOA) to cirrhosis of the liver. Yesterday, as I was going through his clothing to donate to the veterans Hospital, I ended up finding his favorite shirt. As I grabbed the shirt and started to hug it, I noticed it smelt like him and I completely lost it. I just sat there ugly crying and hugging his shirt. After a few minutes, I decided it was too much and that I wasn’t ready to give his things away yet, so I put his clothing away. I go to the bathroom to blow my nose and clean my face up a little. I noticed I had black streaks of eyeliner all over my face and transfer marks on my top eyelids. Now granite most eyeliner and mascara will run with a good cry. However, waterproof makeup isn’t supposed to run that bad. I can say that with 100% confidence as I had on a different brand of waterproof gel eyeliner the day of his memorial service where I cried even longer and harder without any black streaks on my face.All in all it’s an OK product but it isn’t as waterproof as others and I do not recommend wearing it if you’re an emotional wreck or going to the pool.

Still enjoying this like 3 years later. It's now dried up but Im not throwing it away. May be i'll soften it. But this is a good buy.

This is excellent eyeliner. It lasts longer than 24 hours and it doesn’t run or smear! I will use this from now on!

Love the brow tint, so creamy and easy to apply. You just need very little. The black eyeliner isn't as waterproof as described, but i do love the intense blackness and creaminess when applying. Think I'll try drying it a lil next time to see of that helps it last longer next time.