MAYBELLINENew York Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Waterproof Eyeliner, Satin Finish, Pitch Brown

For the price, this pen is a winner! The quality is exceptional – the formula is smooth, the color stays the same and the pen is easy to control. It's definitely waterproof and incredibly durable. I'm amazed at how well it stays in place all day. It's fantastic value for money. I'll definitely be repurchasing again.

I’m not a makeup guru by any means but I LOVE this eyeliner. I like the liquid way better than pencil because it glides on so smoothly and the pigment is awesome. I originally started using this in the black color (sold at CVS, Target, pretty much anywhere - but it’s cheapest on Amazon!) and wanted to try the Pitch Brown for a softer eyeliner look. Any time I’ve purchased this color in stores, it’s always had no pigment and felt really watered down (no idea why and I hate it). I literally refuse to buy this from anywhere other than Amazon because of that.Anyways back to the actual eyeliner, it’s water resistant, stays on all day without setting spray so long as you aren’t aggressively rubbing your eyes. It’s pretty durable too. One pen can last me well over a month with daily use. The only thing to be wary of - do not leave the cap off for extended periods of time as it will dry out easily and be careful when putting the cap on. If I put it on at an angle when I’m rushing, the bristles will ruin the fine point and poke out (this tends to happen over time too, around the 3 week mark). I fix it by just using some nail clippers to clip off the bristles that are sticking out because they poke my eye when I’m applying.That aside, this is my go to eyeliner and I refuse to buy or try anything else lol

great liner, dark brown, and brush is well defined. I keep mine brush end down in makeup organizer then lightly shake before using. is truly waterproof, on mornings ive forgotten to remove night before, makeup is still fresh. I dont recommend leaving on overnight for eye health. I use a mineral water type remover.

I really love this eyeliner. It goes on easy, doesn’t smudge unless of course you make a mistake and try to fix it. It’s waterproof. I would have given this 5 stars if it wasn’t for how the brush will start to split (for lack of better words). If you cut off the piece of the brush that is sticking out, then it starts to leak. ( usually this is after several uses) I’m Sure this is due to how you put the cap back on but I’ve tried to be so careful at not catching any of the brush hairs by taking my time and gently putting the cap on but no matter how gentle I am, eventually it will still happen. Another problem is that sometimes after several uses sometimes sooner, it will start to leak at the base of the brush, forming a bubble which gets all over your hands if you don’t notice in time. When these things happen, there’s still plenty of product left so it’s a shame to have to toss it because it won’t perform as well however I usually get plenty of use out of the product before these things happen and I will say that I have had these problems with other brands of this type of eyeliner and this brand isn’t as bad as others, performs better and is cheaper. It’s also much cheaper on Amazon than the stores especially with a subscription so I usually get my money’s worth before I start having trouble. I keep one extra on hand in case the one I have is giving me too much trouble.

This stuff is indeed very easy to put on. More importantly, it's easy to get it looking good. Some are quick to apply and you find yourself grabbing a makeup remover immediately to try and undo the mistakes.Great color, seems to stay on throughout the day. Haven't been on a bike ride yet but that will be the real test! Came off with remover from my hand quickly, so that's good too.Like it enough that I'm buying another for my daughter.Recommended.

I have to agree with other reviewers. I like the eyeliner, however, the hairs of the brush start splitting after using it awhile. I do my best to put the cap on carefully, but it still splits. Also, if you accidentally leave the cap off for a time (couldn't find it rolled on the dark floor), the mascara is unforgiving and dries out completely.

I don't ever leave reviews, but I am stunned. I was using sephora wink it eyeliner for years. It's only alittle more expensive, but it was great, but did wear throughout the day. I was looking for another eyeliner that was alittle cheaper and so I didn't have to run to sephora (more expensive online). So I found this one.I always have issues with alot of eyeliners, cheap, expensive, doesn't matter, transferring onto my eyelids, or wearing off throughout the day, but this eyeliner drys almost instantly. No transfer. Even throughout the day (oily eyelids). It goes on nice and smooth, easy to make the perfect wing. Lasts all day, no smudge. I fell asleep last night with it on. I woke up and looked in the mirror, and my wings were still pretty in tact! And I definitely know i was rubbing my eyes. You do need to wash your face pretty good to remove it all, but honestly this is my new favorite, that they're probably going to discontinue it now, because I love it so much. I really hope they dont..Enjoy it while you can!

I love it! It gave me fuller looking eyebrows I love the color I highly recommend it blended well with my eyebrows.